Scroll to explore

Employment & Workers Comp

Paid Staff vs. Volunteers: Getting Your Workers’ Comp Classification Right

Job titles don't determine employment classification — the working relationship does. Getting it wrong can affect payroll tax, wage law, and how an injury claim gets handled.

Questions Before Renewing Coverage

Getting employee classification right matters for more than just workers’ compensation — it affects payroll tax obligations, wage and hour law, and how a claim gets handled if someone is hurt. For a small church or nonprofit juggling paid staff, stipended roles, and volunteers, it’s an area where good intentions can still lead to real mistakes.

Job title alone doesn’t determine classification. What generally matters is the nature of the relationship: does the organization control how and when the work is done, is the person paid on a regular schedule, and do they perform duties central to the organization’s operations. A “volunteer coordinator” who works a set schedule for a stipend and reports to a supervisor may, in practice, look more like an employee than the title suggests, regardless of what anyone intended when the role was created.

Misclassification tends to surface at the worst possible moment — after an injury, when a workers’ comp carrier or the state determines that someone the church considered a volunteer should have been covered as an employee, or vice versa. This can affect not just whether a claim is paid, but whether the organization faces penalties for not carrying required coverage in the first place.

The most reliable fix is a periodic review — annually is reasonable for most small organizations — of every paid and stipended role against Montana’s classification guidelines, done alongside whoever handles payroll and your insurance agent. It’s a modest time investment that meaningfully reduces the chance of an unpleasant surprise tied to a classification nobody double-checked.

Action Items

  • List every paid and stipended role and note who supervises, schedules, and pays them.
  • Run each role against Montana’s employee-vs-volunteer classification guidelines annually.
  • Loop in your payroll contact for the annual classification review.

This post is for general informational purposes only and isn’t legal or insurance advice — classification rules involve real nuance, so please talk with a licensed insurance professional and, for wage and classification questions, an employment attorney or the Montana Department of Labor and Industry.

Helland Insurance